Imagine two organizations that want roughly the same software. The first sends a one-page feature list to several firms and gets back proposals whose prices and timelines differ several times over and cannot be put side by side. The second sends a clear RFP and gets proposals whose assumptions, phasing and risks can actually be compared. The difference is not the quality of the firms. It is the quality of the request. A proposal is never more precise than the request it answers.
This guide is for managers who want to hand the build of a software system to a team outside their organization. It explains what an RFP is, how it differs from an RFI, an RFQ and a tender, which sections it needs, and which mistakes make proposals worthless. It also includes a 12-section template you can use as is.
Summary for managers
- An RFP describes the problem, the constraints and the selection criteria, and asks several teams to propose a solution, a timeline and a cost.
- A good RFP describes the problem, not the solution, and gives real user scenarios instead of a bare feature list.
- Three things have the biggest effect on how accurate proposals are: prioritized requirements, non-functional requirements and a budget range.
- If you cannot yet write the requirements down precisely, define a short, separate Discovery phase instead of a detailed RFP.
What is an RFP?
RFP stands for Request for Proposal. In this document an organization describes its need and asks several firms to submit a proposal covering the solution, delivery approach, team, timeline and cost. That is the main difference between an RFP and a request for a quote: an RFP does not only ask for a price, it asks for the solution and the reasoning behind it.
Writing an RFP helps the organization before it helps any bidder. When you have to put goals, users, priorities and budget on paper, internal disagreements surface before the project starts, not halfway through it.
RFP vs. RFI vs. RFQ vs. tender
These terms are often used interchangeably, but each answers a different question.
| Document or process | The question it asks | When to use it |
|---|---|---|
| RFI (Request for Information) | What solutions and which firms are out there? | When you do not know the market yet, or are not sure what you need |
| RFP (Request for Proposal) | How would you solve this problem, with which team, in what time and at what cost? | When the problem is clear but the solution should come from the bidder |
| RFQ (Request for Quotation) | How much does this defined item cost? | When you know exactly what you want, such as licenses or hardware |
| Tender | — | The formal, regulated purchasing process of government and public bodies |
A custom software project almost always needs an RFP, not an RFQ. Two good teams may propose two very different solutions to the same problem, and that difference is exactly what you need to assess.
Many public procurement systems use a two-envelope, or two-stage, process for this kind of purchase: technical proposals are scored first, and price envelopes are opened only for bidders who passed the technical threshold. A good RFP follows the same logic: quality of the solution first, price second. A private organization is not bound to this order, but it benefits from following it.
When you need an RFP, and when you do not
Not every purchase needs an RFP. Writing and evaluating a serious one takes time, both for your organization and for the firms that respond.
An RFP is worth it when:
- The project is large, long or critical to the business.
- Several internal stakeholders have to agree on the requirements.
- You want to compare several firms fairly, against the same criteria.
- The organization must be able to show later how and why the choice was made.
A detailed RFP is not needed when:
- The project is small; a two- or three-page statement of work and a good meeting are enough.
- You are working with a partner you have already worked with successfully.
- You do not know yet what you want. In that case, send an RFI first or define a Discovery phase (explained below).
What makes a good RFP
Before the template, five principles that decide the quality of every section:
1. Describe the problem, not the solution. "A mobile app built with framework X" is a solution. "Field sales staff in small towns must be able to place orders without a stable internet connection" is a problem. If you have a real technical constraint, for example your in-house team only maintains one programming language, state it with the reason. Otherwise leave the choice of tools to the bidder and ask them to justify it.
2. Give scenarios, not just a feature list. "User management" means something different to every team. "A branch manager can add new staff, but access to financial reports is granted only with head-office approval" means the same thing to everyone. That is why organizations that take RFPs seriously ask for specific use cases rather than a list of features, and include demos and conversations in the selection process.
3. Prioritize. Put every requirement into one of three groups: "must have", "should have" and "if budget and time allow". Without priorities, every firm prices everything, and you have no way to reduce scope except by renegotiating.
4. Use numbers, not adjectives. "Fast", "secure" and "scalable" cannot be priced. "Search responds in under one second for most requests, with 500 concurrent users at peak" can. The numbers in this example are illustrative; take the real ones from the current state of your own business.
5. Announce the selection criteria in advance. A firm that knows "similar experience" and "quality of delivery approach" weigh more than "lowest price" writes a different proposal.
A 12-section software RFP template
There is no single standard structure for an RFP. These 12 sections are what an engineering team needs to give a reliable estimate. For a smaller project you can merge sections, but it is better not to drop any of them.
| # | Section | What to write | Key question |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Summary and goal | On one page: what problem, for whom, and which metric defines success | If the project succeeds, which number will have changed six months later? |
| 2 | Organization and context | The business, the market, the size of the organization, and why this project is happening now | What would a bidder guess wrong without this section? |
| 3 | Current state | Existing systems and tools, data volumes, today's workflow, and whether existing code is available | What gets replaced, and what has to stay? |
| 4 | Users and scenarios | Roles, number of users per role, and 5 to 15 main end-to-end scenarios | What is the most important thing each role does in the system? |
| 5 | Functional requirements | Features, each with a priority of "must / should / if possible" | If we had half the budget, which ones would stay? |
| 6 | Non-functional requirements | Performance, availability, security, data privacy, platforms, languages and right-to-left support | What does one hour of downtime cost? |
| 7 | Integrations and constraints | Internal systems, payment gateway, SMS, identity, and where it will be hosted (on-premise, local cloud or international cloud) | Which systems must we connect to, and is their integration documentation ready? |
| 8 | Scope and deliverables | Who does UI/UX design, testing, deployment, documentation, training, data migration; and explicitly what is out of scope | What exactly do we receive on delivery day? |
| 9 | Budget and timeline | The budget range, which dates are truly fixed, and why | Which date would actually hurt us if it moved? |
| 10 | Ownership and contract | Ownership of code and data, access to the repository and infrastructure, payment model, acceptance period, warranty and confidentiality | If the engagement ends, what is in our hands? |
| 11 | Response format | What you want from bidders: technical approach, phasing, team, similar work, assumptions and risks, cost per phase, support model; with a page limit | Can the responses be compared line by line? |
| 12 | Process and evaluation criteria | Timeline (issue, question deadline, Q&A session, presentations, selection), criteria weights and a point of contact | Does the bidder know how they will be selected? |
Two sections of this template are ignored more than the rest, and cost more than the rest: section 6 and section 10.
Non-functional requirements (section 6) are usually the things an organization takes for granted, and leaving them out means each firm has priced its own assumption. A system that must always be available, with regular backups, error monitoring and fast rollback, costs something entirely different from a system that can tolerate a few hours of downtime. Two more questions belong in this section: must the system be hosted in a specific country or region for data residency reasons, and if it depends on an external service, what happens if that service becomes unavailable?
Section 10 is usually left for the contract, yet it directly affects price. Ownership of the code, the domain, the payment gateway accounts and the servers should be in the organization's name from day one. If the code stays in the vendor's repository and the servers sit under the vendor's account, you have created a dependency that makes changing technology partners very expensive later.
Common mistakes in software RFPs
These mistakes do not make an RFP useless; worse, they produce proposals that look comparable but are not.
A feature list without priorities. Everything gets priced, proposals come back expensive, and reducing scope turns into a draining negotiation.
Hiding the budget. The usual worry is that if you state a budget, everyone will propose exactly that number. But when you do not state it, one firm prices a minimal version and another a complete product, and you end up with two proposals for two different projects. A budget range lets bidders design the solution to your size. Even saying "what scale this project is" is better than complete silence.
Prescribing technology without a reason. When you have already chosen the tools, you have set aside the most valuable part of the bidder's expertise. If you have a real reason, write it down; if not, ask each bidder to explain their choice.
Unclear boundaries of responsibility. Who handles UI design, content, migrating data from the old system and acceptance testing? Clear boundaries make the work simpler. For example, in the rewrite of a widely used digital health app, UI/UX design came from the client, while building the React Native version and quality assurance were the Dropp team's responsibility. Because that boundary was clear from the start, both sides knew what they were delivering.
Ignoring the day after delivery. Software does not end on delivery day. Who maintains the servers, monitors errors, applies security updates and fixes post-release bugs? If the RFP says nothing about warranty and support, proposals become incomparable in this area too.
A short deadline and no chance to ask questions. An RFP that gives two weeks to respond and no way to ask questions gets proposals full of guesswork. Set a clear deadline for questions and send every answer to all bidders, so everyone proposes on the same information.
Evaluating on price alone. The cheapest proposal is often the one that has pushed the most assumptions out of scope. Before comparing prices, put the "assumptions and exclusions" section of each proposal side by side.
How to evaluate proposals
Good evaluation starts before the proposals arrive, with the scoring table you announced in section 12. A sample weighting for a custom software project (adjust the weights to your own priorities):
| Criterion | Sample weight |
|---|---|
| Understanding of the problem and quality of the proposed solution | 30% |
| Delivery approach: testing, deployment, documentation and risk management | 20% |
| Similar experience and team composition | 20% |
| Cost and payment model | 20% |
| Post-delivery support and knowledge transfer | 10% |
A few practical points alongside this table:
- Technical first, then price. Score the technical proposals before you see the prices. The same logic as two-stage tendering keeps price from influencing technical judgment.
- Pay attention to questions. A team that asks precise questions before pricing has usually taken the problem more seriously. A fixed price for a vague scope, without a single question, is not a good sign.
- Meet the real team. In the presentation, talk to the people who will actually work on the project, not only the sales team.
- Ask architecture questions. Which technical decisions get expensive later, and how has the bidder thought about them? We listed those questions in Software Architecture for Managers.
When you cannot write everything down in advance
Sometimes a precise RFP is not possible: the product is new, the users are not defined yet, or the legacy system is so complex that it cannot be estimated without reviewing the code. Insisting on a fixed price for the whole project then means either the bidder covers the risk with a high price, or wins with a low price and makes up for it later with change requests.
A better route is a short, separate Discovery phase: a few weeks of joint work whose output is a requirements document, a proposed architecture, a prototype and a phased estimate. After that you either continue with the same team, or turn that output into a precise RFP and invite proposals from several firms.
The Dropp engineering team follows the same logic in its own proposals. Wherever a decision depends on information that is not yet available, we mark it explicitly as a Discovery decision rather than hiding a guess in the price. Payments are staged against milestones, and each phase carries a two-month warranty after release. These are exactly the things we suggest you ask for in section 10 of your own RFP.
Checklist before sending an RFP
If the answer to any of these questions is "no", the RFP is not ready to send.
- Is the project goal written with a measurable metric?
- Are the main user scenarios described end to end?
- Does every requirement have a priority?
- Are non-functional requirements, including hosting location and data sensitivity, written with numbers?
- Are the systems to integrate with, and the state of their documentation, identified?
- Is what is out of scope written down explicitly?
- Are the budget range and fixed dates stated, with reasons?
- Is ownership of code, data and infrastructure defined in the organization's name?
- Is the response format defined so proposals can be compared line by line?
- Are the evaluation criteria and their weights announced, and is there a way to ask questions?
Conclusion
A good RFP is not a purchasing form; it is a thinking tool. An organization that has written down its problem, priorities, constraints and selection criteria clearly gets proposals it can genuinely compare, and fewer surprises in the contract and in delivery.
If you are preparing an RFP for a software project, or have a draft you would like an engineering review of before sending, the Dropp team can work alongside you as an engineering partner. More details are on our software design and development services page.
Frequently asked questions
What is an RFP?
An RFP, or Request for Proposal, is a document in which an organization describes its need or problem and asks several firms to propose how they would solve it, including the solution, delivery approach, team, timeline and cost.
What is the difference between an RFP and an RFQ?
An RFQ asks only for the price of a defined item and is useful when you know exactly what you want. An RFP also asks the bidder for the solution, which makes it the right fit for projects such as custom software, where there is more than one right way to solve the problem.
Who should write the RFP?
One person should own the document, with input from the business owner, key users, the technical lead, finance and, where needed, legal. If you use an outside consultant to write it, that consultant should not also bid on the same RFP.
How long should a software RFP be?
There is no fixed length. The test is whether a bidder can give a reliable estimate without guessing. Keep the main text short and precise, and put bulky details, such as sample data or documentation of existing systems, in appendices.
How many firms should receive the RFP?
Three to five firms, shortlisted in advance through an RFI or a review of their past work, is usually enough. Sending it to many firms makes evaluation heavy, and serious firms invest less time in a request that has obviously gone to everyone.